11 things we learned about Biodiversity Net Gain with Julia Baker, Mott MacDonald
As part of the Green Finance Topic Advisory Group, we spoke with Julia Baker, Technical Director for Natural Services and Global Sub‑Market Lead for Biodiversity & Nature at Mott MacDonald.
With over 20 years’ experience and a central role in shaping the UK’s biodiversity net gain (BNG) journey, Julia offered a practitioner’s perspective on how BNG is functioning in practice, where it is transformative, where it is struggling, and what is needed next.
England’s BNG programme aims to create a regulated market for nature by linking development directly to measurable biodiversity improvements. Julia’s reflections help illuminate whether the system is delivering ecological value, a functioning market, and a credible long‑term framework for nature recovery. Read below for the key insights.
1. BNG has been transformative in bringing nature into decision‑making earlier than ever
BNG has fundamentally shifted how development teams engage with nature. What was once peripheral is now central to the process with nature services teams integral to the decision-making process.
This shift is the result of a decade of groundwork from voluntary good‑practice principles (2016) to seven iterations of the biodiversity metric. The statutory requirement has accelerated cultural change across major projects, embedding ecological considerations into the project lifecycle.
2. The statutory 10% requirement and the broader policy ambition are not yet aligned
A recurring theme was the gap between minimum legal compliance and the wider ambition for nature recovery. The metric provides a proxy for biodiversity, but it cannot capture the full policy narrative around “better places for nature and people.”
Large developers can pursue those ambitions; small developers cannot. This misalignment risks creating uneven outcomes and missed opportunities.
3. Small developers need streamlined pathways and proportionate requirements
BNG currently places disproportionate burdens on small projects. Many small developments historically contributed to biodiversity loss, but they cannot absorb the same technical and financial demands as major infrastructure.
Emerging solutions include:
- Earth‑observation‑based assessments
- Simple levy‑style payments
- Automated habitat calculations
These could offer proportionate, low‑friction routes to compliance.
4. Climate resilience must be embedded into BNG design, delivery and monitoring
BNG’s 30‑year requirement forces practitioners to confront climate uncertainty. Habitats will face extreme heat, drought, storms, pests and pathogens. Resilience is not optional, it is essential for compliance.
Key needs include:
- Resilient habitat design (e.g., drainage channels, landscape connectivity, good soil function)
- Extreme weather response plans
- Monitoring of resilient measures, not just habitat condition
- Pricing and planning for pest/disease management over decades
5. The nature market is still immature and requires targeted government support
The early years of mandatory BNG exposed the fragility of the emerging market:
- Offset providers received the “rule book” only on day one.
- Registration costs and technical requirements were high.
- Local Nature Recovery Strategies were published late, requiring retrofitting.
- Watercourse units remain extremely scarce.
Market confidence is the foundation of a functioning system. Targeted government intervention, particularly for rivers and complex habitats, could unlock supply and accelerate market maturity.
6. Collaboration across the supply chain is strong but uneven
The offset market now includes:
- National NGOs (e.g., Wildlife Trusts)
- Local wildlife groups
- Brokers offering matchmaking and bespoke services
- Landowners responding to demand signals
The sector is highly collaborative, but the narrative of how these layers interact is still poorly understood, and many providers are still getting up to speed.
7. The UK’s approach is influencing global policy and practice
BNG is attracting international attention. Julia and other BNG experts from the UK have briefed delegates the Government of Japan, who are exploring how legislation can fuel a nature market, not just regulate development.
There is also an adaption of the English biodiversity metric into a European biodiversity metric, demonstrating the ripple effect of the UK’s early leadership.
“It’s undeniable… one of the first pieces of legislation that is changing how development interacts with nature” says Baker.
8. Policy gaps remain, particularly around biodiversity footprinting and upstream impacts
BNG is site‑based, but major projects have significant upstream biodiversity impacts through materials, transport, water use and supply chains.
Biodiversity footprinting should sit alongside carbon, water and modern slavery reporting. Industry is already moving voluntarily (e.g., adopters of the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) framework), but clear policy direction is needed.
9. Monitoring, data flow and digital integration are still weak points
A major practical barrier is the disconnect between digital data and on‑site delivery. GIS data often ends up locked in PDFs, never reaching maintenance contractors.
BNG success depends on:
- Digital‑first data transfer
- Clear Habitat Management & Monitoring Plans (HMMPs)
- Pricing and planning for long‑term risks
- Consistent enforcement
Without this, monitoring risks becoming a “tick‑box exercise.”
10. What practitioners need next in three clear messages for policymakers
- Explicit policy guidance on climate resilience in BNG: Resilience is inherent in the 30‑year requirement, but explicit guidance would accelerate consistent practice.
- Government support to accelerate the nature market: Especially for watercourses and complex habitats where market forces alone will not deliver supply.
- A clear policy direction on biodiversity footprinting: To bring biodiversity onto equal footing with carbon and other sustainability agendas.
11. Research priorities: biodiversity footprinting, resilience science and AI impacts
Julia identified three areas where research could meaningfully support practitioners:
- Robust biodiversity footprinting methodologies
- Understanding habitat thresholds under climate stress
- Designing AI infrastructure (data centres, water use, land use) to be nature‑positive
These would provide the evidence base needed for better tools, better decisions and more resilient outcomes.
Julia Baker’s insights reveal a system that is transformative but still maturing. BNG has shifted culture, elevated nature in decision‑making and catalysed a new market, but gaps remain in alignment, resilience, monitoring, and upstream impacts.
With targeted support, clearer policy direction and continued collaboration, BNG can evolve from a compliance mechanism into a powerful driver of nature recovery and climate resilience.
Professor Ania Zalewska
Green Finance
Matthew Orman
Communications
Subscribe to our Newsletter
A quarterly update of all LUNZ Hub activities, events and news stories.